Mini brownie trifles (aka blah brownies in disguise)

I'm going to fill you in on one of my dirty little secrets. If you're ever at my house and I serve you a trifle, it's because a baking project has gone wrong. In this case, it was brownies that had a case of the blahs.

The brownies were yet another example of my not using my judgment in the kitchen. The recipe came from a Southern Living cookbook called Our Readers Top-Rated Recipes. I chose a recipe called Basic Brownies from it, even though my favorite brownie recipes have both cocoa powder and melted unsweetened chocolate in them, and this one had only melted unsweetened chocolate. I thought surely if those vaunted Southern cooks had rated them highly, they'd be good. They weren't, at least to my taste. These had a muted chocolate flavor, even with the addition to a cup of semisweet chocolate chips stirred into the batter. I suppose if you didn't like a strong chocolate flavor (which I can't even imagine), these might be considered good, because the texture was reasonably chewy. I decided to use my cute mini trifle dishes to perk them up.

Many trifles call for you to crumble the cake layer, but I wanted chunks of chewy brownies, so I cubed them. For the rest of the layers, I used up odds and ends in the cupboard and freezer, including a box of chocolate pudding mix, a jar of marshmallow creme and a tub of Cool Whip. I know there are foodies who detest Cool Whip and all that other stuff. So sue me. Even Barbra Streisand (one of my idols) loves Cool Whip. And seriously, are you really going to whip heavy cream to add to pudding mix and marshmallow creme? I think not. Hookayyy ... I think I'm getting a little too defensive here.

My guests devoured the trifles and one male guest said I should sell them to restaurants. Heh heh heh. Come on admit it, even though you know what's in them, you'd like them too.

(Psst ... these are on Tastespotting! I have no idea how they pick what to run, but the site is very popular. It's a great spot to drool over.)

Odds, Ends and Blah Brownie Trifles (that taste great!)
Makes 10 individual trifles
The ingredient list reflects what I had on hand. Use your imagination and inventory as your guide to change sauces, pudding flavors and so on.

1 (8-ounce) package cream cheese, softened
1 (7-ounce) jar marshmallow cream
1 (8-ounce) container frozen whipped topping
1/2 of a 13" by 9" pan of brownies, cubed
1 small package of chocolate fudge pudding (plus milk indicated on package), prepared as directed
1/2 jar caramel sauce (I used Wegmans brand)
3 Skor toffee bars

Beat cream cheese at medium speed with an electric mixer until creamy; beat in marshmallow cream. Stir in 1 container of whipped topping; set mixture aside.

Divide one-third of the brownie pieces in an even layer in the bottom of 10 individual trifle dishes. Spread most of the cream cheese mixture evenly over brownies, reserving about 1/4 of it for garnish. Spread half of the pudding over that. Top with brownie pieces, reserving 33 pieces for a garnish. Finely chop two Skor toffee bars and divide between the dishes. Drizzle with half of the caramel topping. Top with the remaining pudding. Top each trifle with a dollop of the marshmallow mixture. Arrange three brownie pieces on top of each trifle. Drizzle the remaining caramel topping on top. Cut up the remaining toffee bar into 10 pieces and top each trifle with a piece. Cover and chill until serving.


RecipeGirl said...

Hey, I've eaten a good share of Cool Whip in my lifetime!! I love the heavy whipping cream but the Cool Whip doesn't frighten me. And I loooove your Kitchenaid scraper!!

Patsyk said...

I have a container of cool whip in my fridge right now... for the purpose of putting strawberries in a cloud as a dessert for my kids (and me, too!). Quick and easy dessert and everyone is happy.

I love your trifles! May have to bookmark that one to serve to guests sometime soon!

Deborah said...

Your mini trifle dishes are so cute!! I have a brownie trifle recipe that I made years ago that had cubed brownies in it. Your recipe sounds so delicious, and I want to try some!

Brilynn said...

I've done the same thing before! A little whipped cream on top, (or cool whip) can cover any 'mistakes'.

Emily said...

Those are so cute! I love the picture. Congrats on Tastespotting. Sometimes they accept my pictures, sometimes they don't. I'm not sure how they choose.

I wasn't going to stone you for using Cool Whip, don't worry.
But...I don't like Cool Whip. My mom buys it, and I yell at her.

Anonymous said...

Good to know ;-)

Susan from Food Blogga said...

Yikes! These look outrageously delicious!

Anonymous said...


Jenny said...

Mmmm! They are beautiful, and look scrumptious!

Emily said...

Hey, I found this:

About PBO. I think it's a little insulting. I'd feel bad if I were those people.

Tracy said...

Recipegirl, patsyk, deborah, brilynn, caroline, susan & Jenny, thanks for going easy on me. I wasn't sure about posting a recipe with so much packaged stuff in it.

Emiline, I KNOW you don't like Cool Whip! You've mentioned it on your blog! As for the Pillsbury Bake-Off critics, I'm not surprised because this happens every year. I do feel bad for the people who get skewered. People seem to forget that it's AMATEUR cooks coming up with the recipes, not trained chefs.

Tracy said...

Since I can't edit a comment, I realized that my reply may have come across as defensive as the trifle post. I shouldn't post comments at 1:15 a.m. Anyhoo, Emiline is a blogger buddy, and I'm a big fan even if she doesn't like Cool Whip. :-)

Chou said...

Great fix. :)

Anonymous said...

I totally have done this to cover up a botched chocolate cake recipe with peppermint ice cream. Mmmmm.

Anonymous said...

Hey those Mini Trife Brownies look fantastic! I will try them for sure. Why is it that good cooks make everything seem so simple? I would have just eaten the brownies or tossed them out ...thanks for the great idea!

Nina Timm said...

What the heck.....I could nibble on those brownie bits all day and never get to the trifles.... and that would be a terrible loss.