Cupcakes from Sugar Mountain Bake Shoppe

I had two wishes for Mother's Day: a new garage door opener (I'm nothing if not practical) and to try the cupcakes at Sugar Mountain Bake Shoppe. So on the Saturday before Mother's Day, while my husband and 16-year-old son worked on the garage door, my younger son and I headed to the trendy Park Avenue area to pick out cupcakes.

Oh, the place was charming! The building houses two businesses -- a Victorian tea room during the day, and then it turns into Sugar Mountain Bake Shoppe at 5 p.m. It's unusual for a bakery to open at 5 p.m., but I can see why it could work in the Park Avenue area, which is home to lots of young adults. I'll bet they pick up cupcakes on their way home from work, or stop in for coffee and cupcakes with friends. (They also serve food but I didn't pay much attention to the menu.)

The building has small rooms. Some are decorated in a Victorian style and some have a more current look. There's also a cute front porch -- I'd love to go there with friends.

They bake a lot of different flavors -- their website says 85 -- and different ones are on display each day. Or, you can order a dozen or more of your favorites with 24 hours notice. Each flavor was frosted differently and every one was gorgeous. It was tough to decide which eight to choose (we picked two for each of us -- one for Saturday and one for Sunday). Here's what we eventually selected:

Devil’s Twist : Dark chocolate cake with a white cream filling, dipped in chocolate ganache -- it looked like a Hostess cupcake.
Cookies and Cream: Dark chocolate cake with a chocolate cookie crust filled with white cream, topped with white chocolate buttercream and chunks of crushed chocolate cookies. My 13-year-old son devoured it the moment we got home on Saturday. I barely had time to snap this picture..
Cappuccino: Chocolate espresso cake filled with mocha ganache, topped with coffee buttercream. My 16-year-old son gave it a thumbs-up.
White Russian: Vanilla cake baked with kahlua and vodka, filled with kahlua chocolate ganache, topped with mocha buttercream. This was my favorite -- my husband's, too.
Chocolate Peanut Butter: Dark chocolate cake with peanut butter cream filling, topped with peanut butter buttercream. I thought the peanut butter filling and frosting obliterated the flavor of the chocolate cake.

What I didn't love:
- The cakes. They were light and a bit crumbly. My personal preference is a denser, moist cake. And I felt that the chocolate flavors could have had a more pronounced chocolate flavor.
- If I'm really being nitpicky, the cakes had "muffin tops." While I like them on muffins, I thought they made the cupcakes a little awkward to eat. But that's truly nitpicking.

What I loved: 
- The way they looked. You eat with your eyes first, and these were artfully done.

- All of the fillings and frostings. They were light and fluffy, not as sweet and heavy as typical bakery buttercreams.

Sugar Mountain Bake Shoppe set a benchmark for my upcoming cupcake baking projects -- I'm going to give more thought to how I decorate various flavors. I'll also be sure to go back with a friend and enjoy a cupcake on their porch in the summer.

Sugar Mountain Bake Shoppe on Urbanspoon


MegSmith @ Cooking.In.College said...

Oooo my goodness...those cupcakes look AMAZING!!! I want the cookies and cream one so bad. I love Oreos :-)

Happy Belated Mother's Day!!!!

Karen Harris said...

Oh, these look so good! I don't know how you managed to just pick a few and not come home with 4 or 5 dozen. Great restraint Tracy. Happy Mother's Day!

Anonymous said...

They are beautiful, but I like a dense cake too. I want to dunk my finger in the frosting of each cupcake :)

ErikaCatherine said...

Completely disgusting and dissatisfied! My cupcake was obviously not fresh and extremely dry. And minutes after leaving I experienced a severe allergic reaction because they do not label or separate their cupcakes for severe food allergies! Nuts should not be in a case with other foods! Especially in a small bakery. When I contacted the owner I was never even given an apology! Completely disrespectful ownership and staff. Would NEVER recommend or go back!

Tracy said...

Erika, it is too bad that you had a bad experience at Sugar Mountain. I have close family and friends with food issues and allergies so I'm sympathetic to your situation. My recollection is that Sugar Mountain had just one display case. Being a small business, they may not have the funds or space or demand to have two separate bakery cases. I'm surprised you didn't see that the nut cupcakes were in the same display case as the others. I have a nephew with nut allergies, and I know my sister wouldn't have let him order cupcakes from Sugar Mountain because of that. I don't know anything about the Sugar Mountain kitchen, but my experience has been that small businesses also have small kitchens that just don't have the room to keep ingredients separate. You may have better luck with larger businesses that have the space and budget and facilities. Either way, it probably would a good idea to call establishments ahead of time to ask questions instead of making assumptions and putting yourself in a dangerous situation.